Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro and Hall

Buffalo, NY

69
Attorney Index
50 reviews
5.0
Google Rating
437 reviews
Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro and Hall

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

Personal injury attorneyLaw firmAttorneyMedical lawyerTrial attorney

Review Snapshot

50
Total Reviews
High Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
85%
Response Rate
Highly Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 66/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication74
Outcome63
Responsiveness70
Empathy72
Expertise61
Fee Transparency59
Trial Experience63
Satisfaction66

Client Reviews

Jontrell Torres
5 months ago

I would highly recommend Joe Nicastro and his team. They handled my personal injury case with professionalism and care throughout the entire process. From day one, communication was excellent. Any questions I had were addressed promptly, and they always provided clear guidance on what to expect next. I also appreciated that Joe and his team took the time to check in on me to make sure everything was going well. If I was ever unable to reach Joe directly, a member of his team was always available to help, or he would get back to me in a very timely manner. Overall, I had a great experience and truly appreciate the support and dedication they showed during my case. Again, I would highly recommend them and will keep them in mind if I ever have future needs.

pauly kay
5 months ago

Jill is a great person to deal with

Michael Young
6 months ago

Very efficient and enthusiastic great law firm for sure, thanks for all your hardwork Jill..

Susan Blackley2 photos
6 months ago

My wife & I would like to highly recommend Bill Hallett for his excellent representation as our personal injury attorney. We found him to be a good communicator who conscientiously addressed all of our concerns, and balanced candor with sincere compassion for the trauma we had experienced resulting from the injury, and the unexpected fallout that followed it. We were made to feel confident about Bill’s legal acumen because of his knowledgeable presentation and analysis of our legal situation, and all the possible twists and turns that could occur with our case. There were no over-promises, and Bill kept us in the loop with updates whenever they occurred. You will be in capable hands with Bill Hallett and Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro, and Hall, LLC.

Response from owner

Susan, thank you so much for your incredibly thoughtful and generous review.<br><br>We are truly honored that you placed your trust in Bill and the team at Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro, and Hall during such a difficult time. Personal injury cases often come with not only physical challenges, but emotional and unexpected life disruptions as well, and it means a great deal to know that you felt supported, informed, and treated with compassion throughout the process.<br><br>Providing clear communication, honest guidance, and steady advocacy is something we take very seriously. We’re especially grateful for your recognition of Bill’s commitment to keeping you informed and setting realistic expectations every step of the way.<br><br>Thank you again for your recommendation. We wish you both continued healing and all the very best moving forward.

Michele Laney
6 months ago

Great firm!

Response from owner

Michele, we appreciate the 5-star review. Cantor Wolff Nicastro & Hall is proud to provide dedicated personal injury representation.

Chelsey ClawsonLocal Guide8 photos
7 months ago

These guys worked with me from the beginning of my case until the very end, years later & I’m so so so grateful for the entire team! 10/10 would recommend for a personal injury attorney❤️ shout out to Andrew Gill & his whole crew :)

Response from owner

Chelsey, thank you so much for the kind words and the 5-star review! Everyone at Cantor Wolff Nicastro & Hall is grateful for your trust throughout your personal injury case. We’re especially glad to hear your experience with Andrew Gill and the entire team was a positive one. It truly means a lot, and we appreciate the recommendation!

Tyrone PettigrewLocal Guide
7 months ago
Response from owner

Tyrone, thank you for the 5-star review. Our experienced personal injury attorneys are committed to providing strong legal representation and outstanding client service.

melissa slisz
7 months ago

Joe and his team were fantastic to work with. They made me comfortable from the first phone call. I highly recommend.

Response from owner

Melissa, Thank you for taking the time to leave such a kind review. We’re so glad to hear that Joe and his team made you feel comfortable from the very first call - that’s always our goal. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we truly appreciate the trust you placed in our firm.

Matthew Edwards
8 months ago

Sent my case to the firm over Google and received a call within minutes. The firm is very personal and takes care of your case as best they can. Worked with Joe Nicastro and his team to get a fair outcome from my case. If you are looking for an injury firm that combines professionalism with genuine care, this is the one!

Response from owner

Matthew, thank you so much for the 5-star review and for trusting our firm with your case. We’re glad we were able to connect with you quickly and provide the personal attention you deserve. Joe Nicastro and his team take great pride in fighting for fair outcomes while treating every client with care and respect. Your kind words about our professionalism and genuine commitment mean a great deal to us. We truly appreciate the recommendation and wish you all the best moving forward.

Mac FreeleyLocal Guide23 photos
8 months ago

theyer so shady. 4 years an they went dark

Response from owner

Hi Mac,<br>We don't have any client by your name. We would never go dark so my assumption is you have the wrong firm. Can you please call our office at 716-848-8000 and ask for David Wolff? (as of one month later, you have not called. Please contact us to confirm you have the right law firm)<br>

Zariyah Carter
8 months ago

Appreciate everything 💯

Response from owner

Zariyah, thank you for your kind words and recommendation. We’re honored you trusted our personal injury law firm to represent you. Keeping our clients informed, answering questions, and fighting for the best possible outcome are priorities in every injury case we handle. We truly appreciate your support.

Danielle Garguiolo
8 months ago

We were extremely happy with our lawyer he always answered our questions and made sure we were kept informed and fought for us to get the very best outcome ! I highly recommend this law firm

Response from owner

Danielle, thank you so much for your kind words and 5-star review. We’re truly grateful for your recommendation and for trusting our firm with your personal injury case.<br><br>Keeping our clients informed, answering questions promptly, and fighting for the best possible outcome are at the heart of what we do. It means a great deal to know you felt supported and well represented throughout the process.<br><br>We wish you all the best moving forward and sincerely appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.

Gregory Bittner
8 months ago

Andrew was fantastic. He walked me and my wife through every aspect of our personal injury suit. Not knowing much about the process, feeling angry about the incident, and not having any idea what type of compensation was possible, we were uneasy about it all. Andrew was honest, compassionate, and refreshingly to the point. All of our hesitation and confusion was quickly put aside when we first spoke with Andrew. He had a game plan and stuck to it. He always answered our calls, and reached out to us whenever additional information was received. On top of it, he wouldn't settle for anything less than what he thought we deserved. 10/10 for communication and transparency.

Response from owner

Gregory, thank you for sharing such a thoughtful 5-star review. We truly appreciate your trust in our firm during a challenging time.<br><br>Andrew takes great pride in guiding clients through every stage of the personal injury process with honesty, clarity, and compassion - especially when emotions are high and the legal system feels overwhelming. We’re glad to hear he was able to put your concerns at ease, communicate openly, and develop a strong strategy focused on securing the compensation you deserved.<br><br>Your feedback about his communication, transparency, and dedication means a great deal to our team. Thank you for allowing us to represent you and your wife, and we wish you both continued healing and the very best moving forward.

fari holley
8 months ago

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Highly Recommend Attorney William (Bill)! Working with William (Bill) was truly a blessing. From the moment I reached out, he treated my case with urgency, compassion, and real dedication. Bill took the time to explain everything clearly, answered every question with patience, and made sure I always understood what was happening. What stood out the most was how hard he fought for me. He didn’t let anyone push me around or downplay my injuries. He handled every detail, kept me updated, and made the entire process so much less stressful. You can tell he genuinely cares about his clients and takes pride in doing things the right way. Because of Bill’s expertise and determination, I received a result far better than I ever expected. I truly felt supported and protected every step of the way. If you need an injury attorney who is professional, knowledgeable, honest, and absolutely on your side, Bill is the one you want. I’m extremely grateful for everything he did for me!

Response from owner

Fari, thank you so much for this thoughtful and detailed 5-star review. We’re incredibly grateful you took the time to share your experience.<br><br>Bill truly exemplifies what our personal injury firm stands for - urgency, compassion, clear communication, and relentless advocacy for the injured. We’re proud to hear that he made you feel informed, protected, and supported throughout the entire claims process, and that he fought hard to ensure your injuries were taken seriously.<br><br>Achieving a result that exceeded your expectations is exactly what we strive for when representing our clients, and your kind words affirm the dedication Bill brings to every personal injury case.<br><br>Thank you for trusting us during such a difficult time. We wish you continued healing and all the best moving forward.

Alicia Cooley
8 months ago
Response from owner

Alicia, thank you for the 5-star review! We truly appreciate your trust in our personal injury law firm and are honored to advocate for injured clients seeking the justice and compensation they deserve.

Sophia Stines
9 months ago

This firm is filled with passion and kindness from the top down. I can't express my gratitude enough for the work that David Wolff and Paige Hughes have done and continue to do. Truly a firm that goes above and beyond.

Response from owner

Sophia, thank you so much for this incredible review! Our entire firm is committed to treating every personal injury client with compassion and dedication, and we’re grateful you felt that from top to bottom. David Wolff and Paige Hughes work tirelessly to protect our clients’ rights and fight for the results they deserve, and it means a lot to know their efforts made a difference. We appreciate your trust in us and will always go above and beyond for you.

Andrea Scheider
9 months ago

Ali is a great paralegal to deal with

Response from owner

Andrea, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re so glad to hear that Ali (Alissa) was great to work with. She’s a dedicated member of our personal injury team here at Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro & Hall, and we’re proud of the care and support she provides to every client.<br><br>Our firm is committed to guiding injury victims through every step of the process, and it’s wonderful to know Alissa helped make your experience a positive one. If you ever need anything in the future, we’re always here to help.

Grace Ravines
9 months ago

This was a case out of the ordinary and working with Anthony made the whole process smooth. Great communication and a good outcome!

Response from owner

Grace, thank you so much for the 5-star review! We’re glad Anthony was able to guide you through a unique and out-of-the-ordinary personal injury case and make the entire process smooth. Clear communication and strong results are exactly what we strive for, and we’re grateful you trusted us to fight for your outcome. If you ever need anything in the future, we’re here for you.<br>

Jerrica McAndrew
9 months ago

Anthony has been phenomenal to work with. He clearly explains everything and walks you through every part of the process.

Response from owner

Jerrica, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re thrilled to hear that Anthony has been phenomenal to work with. Clear communication is a cornerstone of our personal injury practice at Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro & Hall, and it’s great to know he took the time to explain every step of the process and guide you through your case.<br><br>Our team is committed to making this experience as smooth and supportive as possible. If you ever need anything in the future, we’re always here to help.

Ann Milazzo
9 months ago

"Ali is a great paralegal"

Response from owner

Ann, thank you for the 5-star review! We’re so glad to hear that you had a great experience with Ali. She’s an exceptional paralegal and a key part of our personal injury team here at Cantor, Wolff, Nicastro & Hall.<br><br>Our firm is dedicated to providing skilled, compassionate support to injury victims, and it’s wonderful to know Ali helped deliver the level of care and guidance we pride ourselves on. If you ever need assistance again or have questions about your personal injury case, we’re always here for you.

Contact

Address
959 Kenmore Ave, Buffalo, NY 14223

Google Profile

Rating
5.0 / 5
Reviews
437
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
40

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code