Colorado Lawyer Team

Fort Collins, CO

52
Attorney Index
43 reviews
-
Google Rating
43 reviews

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Review Snapshot

43
Total Reviews
High Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
100%
Response Rate
Highly Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 59/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication60
Outcome60
Responsiveness60
Empathy60
Expertise60
Fee Transparency55
Trial Experience57
Satisfaction60

Client Reviews

Jack Murphy
9 months ago

They were extremely attentive Listening to what I actually had to say And very patient with me while I flip-flopped on what I wanted to decide. Would definitely recommend to my friends and family

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your recommendation! We know every decision is difficult. We are very glad that you trusted us with helping you through that process, though. Can't thank you enough for your own good communication! It was a pleasure working with you and we wish you the best!

Shannon Hall
10 months ago

I would highly recommend this team to anyone who is in need of representation with family law matters. These ladies are thorough, kind, compassionate, and they know the law completely. Justie, Rebecca and the team are 100% committed, professional, and they will guide you every step of the way. I couldn't be happier or more thankful for the guidance and the representation of this one of a kind law firm. 100% and 12 out of 10!! This team is truly amazing!!

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your review, Shannon. We are really glad that you've trusted us with helping you and your family with this difficult situation. We are always here for you, and will be a resource for you always.

Hilary LindLocal Guide7 photos
1 years ago

I had an appointment scheduled and then Rebecca cancelled the Google invite last minute with no reason. I reached out by phone, chat and email and got no response. If they didn't want to talk about my case, that's fine, but at least say so, not just cancel the appointment in Google last minute and not communicate with someone. _______ In response to your reply, I don’t appreciate being gaslit—whether here or via text—into deleting my review. This was my personal experience, and I have every right to share it. I may not be a client now, but there’s a reason for that, and I’m well within my rights to leave feedback. What you stated is simply not true. I’ve quadruple-checked with my brother, and none of this was communicated to him. However, interestingly enough, both of our phone numbers suddenly started working after I left this review… 🤔 To clarify, I scheduled the appointment on my brother’s behalf while he was traveling, but I provided all of HIS direct contact information. He woke up to a cancellation notice, asked me about it, and I immediately called and messaged to confirm whether it was an accident. Yet, no one answered or returned my calls or messages. If your policy is to not allow third-party appointment scheduling, then I should have never been able to make the appointment in the first place, and it was confusing to be able to do that, yet now I am being shamed for calling and trying to confirm something that I did. I was also fully transparent with your intake person about the situation from the beginning. At the end of the day, this was a frustrating and unprofessional experience. Instead of attempting to discredit my review, perhaps focus on taking some accountability and improving communication and policies to prevent future issues like this.

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback about your family member's case and we are sorry our services weren't up to your standards under the circumstances.

Sarah Shutt
1 years ago

I’ve known Rebecca for years and have sought her legal counsel several times. She has practiced in multiple areas and takes the time to explain things to me. She is my go-to for legal advice and representation.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your kind words, Sarah. Rebecca is a great addition to the Team and we're so glad you took the time to review her services.

Angel K.Local Guide206 photos
1 years ago

Cancelled my appointment because they assumed they knew what was going on in my case. Very unprofessional as they could have called and explained further as it might be a complete separate.

Response from owner

Hello Angel. In some cases, we are prohibited from even speaking with a party under our ethical rules and conflicts of interest. We cancel appointments and then follow up with email and calls by staff (to ensure the attorney isn't violating those same rules). You should have received all 3 things today. Please kindly consider removing your review as it is not accurate.

ERIC ALANIZ (EDUB)
2 years ago
Response from owner

Thank you so much for the review!

Michelle Davis
2 years ago

Our son received a DWAI and Justie and Rebecca were BEYOND helpful. I don't know how in the world we would have navigated all the ins and outs of this mess without them. They fought for our son in all the nooks and crannies they could find. If presented with a similar situation, please read this as: HIRE an attorney, most specifically: HIRE these two whizzes! It has been priceless to have their support, knowledge, and overall know how in such a difficult time. Justie further impressed me by answering the phone late afternoon on the Fourth of July! It is obvious they are excellent at what they do and that excellence benefitted our son immensely. THANK YOU!

Response from owner

It was such a pleasure to get to know you and your family. We are so happy to have helped your son. Thank you for such kind words.

Joseph Fuller
3 years ago

I cant say anything bad about this firm i got 9 felony to misdo with this firm and one public defender.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for sharing. We are very glad to have been able to help.

Justin HuffLocal Guide2 photos
3 years ago

This is the second time (and hopefully last time) I have hired the Colorado Lawyer Team to represent me. The first was a criminal case in which Justie's representation was top notch. This time she represented me in a family matter. She was very thurough, taking time to understand my case by speaking directly with my ex-wife which I know she appreciated. In the end Justie was able to help move my case along in the courts, advise me on how to navigate the probation system and was even able to get my probation term terminated 6 months early! I am very appreciateve to have Justie as my lawyer and I highly reccomend the Colorado Lawyer Team to anyone who needs help with criminal or family law! Five Stars!

Response from owner

Thank you for your kind words, Justin. We really enjoyed getting to know you, and I'm looking forward to grabbing a coffee again soon!

Julie Thayer
3 years ago

I highly recommend using the services that the Colorado Lawyer Team can provide. Justie Nicol and her team are quick to respond, are non judgmental and have a thorough understanding of Colorado law. Justie and her team were with me through every step of the court process. They made sure that I understood and I was comfortable with every decision that was made during my case. I can't thank them enough for not only providing excellent representation but for also being kind and compassionate during a difficult time in my life.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for the review. We really appreciate it and are so thankful that you trusted us to work on your case with you.

C LJ1 photo
3 years ago

Colorado Lawyer Team has done a fantastic job in handling my case! They are dedicated and punctual with responses! I am lucky to have been referred to them! Thank you for your services!

Response from owner

Hi KC. Thank you so much for taking the time to review us. We have really enjoyed getting to know you! WE are the lucky ones :)

Luke Cartwright280 photos
3 years ago

Rather disrespectful lawyer that thinks she knows everything there is to know.

Response from owner

Hi John, I’m sorry that you feel this way about one of our attorneys. Can you please kindly inform us of which attorney you are speaking about (we’ve parted ways with two very recently)? We would love to address the breakdown in communication with our firm. It would also really help to know who you are… so we can review where things went wrong… Please contact us via phone at 9706700738 to be connected to an owner who can assist. <br><br>Also, though, as attorneys we DO pride ourselves on knowing everything there is to know about our respective area of law. That is quite literally what folks hire us for! Having a knowledgeable attorney can be a good thing!

Brook Coyne
4 years ago

Quick responses.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for the feedback on our communication!

Djdnsjd Djdjs
4 years ago

Not the finest outfit out there.

Response from owner

We are sorry you feel that the representation was not to your standards. We note--after your initial review and we posted our response, you updated your review. That's ok. Totally your prerogative. If you've got any substantive feedback, we'd love to hear it!

Eric Brazel
5 years ago

I contacted the law firm to discuss a criminal case. Justie called me ASAP to discuss my case. The initial call was a consultation but it felt like I was being taken care of by a lawyer that I already paid. She guided me through the cluster I was in. I was amazed by the service provided to me. The firm offers great rates and options. I was really down before talking with Justie but after talking with her I felt I could breath. They are just a phone call away.

Response from owner

Glad to speak with you about your case, Eric. We're glad to put your mind at ease and provide resources for other issues affecting your life in this kind of situation. We wish you the best of luck, and thank you for taking the time to leave us a review.

Weston Sandfort
5 years ago

My free consultation was incredibly helpful, and Justie Nicol pointed me in a direction to solve my legal issue affordably. She's an honest and helpful professional that I would recommend to my friends or family.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for taking the time to write in for us, Weston. It was a pleasure speaking with you, and we love nothing more than telling someone they don't actually need us and that "you got this"! Glad this will all work out for you soon.

General DeliveryLocal Guide
5 years ago

In reading all the great reviews I wonder why I am being treated so differently. Any attempt at communication is met with divisiveness, avoidance, if not out right hostility. Nothing is being explained. No communication. It's been hard in large part because of the way I've been treated by attorneys. I hope Jennifer is helping me. I know they have contractors who are. There is just so little communication, and any there is is met with impatience. Unreturned phone calls, scathing e-mails or zero response to emails. I am not being kept up do date on issues. Lack of communication causes more stress than the issue itself. Knowing you can't reach your attorney if you need to, more stress. It's already stressful without his on top of it. I'm being made to feel like a bother. I can only hope she and her team are working in the background, but it would be good to understand what is happening. No I'm not leaving my real name.

Response from owner

Hi, although we'd love to be able to address these concerns, we really can't do so unless you let us know who you are. As one of Jenn's partner's at the firm, I'm happy to address any communications issues you feel you're experiencing head on. I'm happy to provide the scheduling link so you can book a call with Jenn ANY time (just click here: https://www.COLawTeamScheduling.as.me.) and you can actually use that link to book a call with her assistant, Debby, any time, too. I welcome you to email me any time you have concerns, too, and I can get you taken care of: Justie@COLawTeam.com. We take this kind of thing seriously here, and we want to make it right. Please reach out directly, and we'll see what we can do to rectify the situation. Perhaps it's something simple like Gmail being down this last week, or a spam filter not letting your emails through. Maybe it's just that we're in a waiting game with the DA or the Courts (COVID has pushed everything out). BUT, we should be communicating regular updates to you even if there is not anything substantive to update you about. And in any case, this is a problem and let's fix it. Please reach out!

Yana Brown
5 years ago

Jennifer and the rest of the team are amazing. The time, effort, and care that they put into helping me through one of the most stressful times in my life is unmatched. Their dedication to me as a client exceeded my expectations. Any questions I had were answered, any concerns that came about where matched with suggestions that would help my case, and most importantly they were honest and straight forward with me. They prepared me for the best and worst case scenarios and made me feel comfortable when approaching a court hearing. I would highly recommend reaching out to Jennifer and her team if you come across any legal trouble. And a personal thank you to Jennifer and everything she did for me!

Response from owner

Yana, thank you so much for your review. We do pride ourselves on honesty and good communication and we love this kind of feedback. You are going to go on to great things! Thank you, thank you, thank you.

Hoax North
5 years ago
Response from owner

Well... I guess we can't win them all. However, we have never represented anyone by this name or had any dealings with a person under this name to our knowledge. Wish they'd have told us why they left a one star review or at least communicated with us prior to posting it so we could address the issue. Alas, we are truly sorry to have offended... someone... somewhere...sometime...

Gabe Parker
6 years ago

Mrs. Jennifer Gersch really helped me get my life back on track. Mrs. Gersch helped me every step of the way and continues to help me after it is all taken care of! She genuinely cared about me and gave me all the support and confidence to face my battle! Thank you for taking care of me!!

Response from owner

Gabe, it has been such a pleasure getting to know you and help you through this difficult situation! We are very happy to have made a difference for you.

Contact

Google Profile

Reviews
43
Claimed
No

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code