John Miller Carroll Law Office

region, WI

63
Attorney Index
20 reviews
3.6
Google Rating
67 reviews
John Miller Carroll Law Office

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

Criminal justice attorneyAttorneyPersonal injury attorney

Review Snapshot

20
Total Reviews
Moderate Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
20%
Response Rate
Low Response
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 73/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication75
Outcome74
Responsiveness74
Empathy76
Expertise73
Fee Transparency67
Trial Experience69
Satisfaction72

Client Reviews

Kurt Krueger
9 months ago
Mercedes Ly1 photo
11 months ago

John is an exceptional attorney. He’s extremely intelligent, confident, and truly knows his way around the law. From the moment I retained him, I knew I was in capable hands. His professionalism and deep understanding of the legal system gave me complete peace of mind throughout the process. Thanks to John’s hard work and expertise, my case had a very positive outcome and I’m incredibly grateful to finally be able to put it behind me. I couldn’t have done it without him. Highly recommend!

Zach Schulz
1 years ago

John Miller Carroll is an amazing criminal defense attorney, I was charged with possession of cocaine and was being offered probation. Due to past negative experiences while on supervision ending in revocation I rejected probation. The District Attorney wanted me to receive 1 year in county jail, John made an argument and I received a punishment half of that length plus good time and Huber work release. Overall I am pleased with the results that John Miller Carroll delivered on my case, due to this I have since went out of my way to Retain John as my lawyer on Other Open Criminal Case that I am currently facing and I would like to say that John Miller Carroll is an amazing Criminal Defense Attorney, Husband, and Father. I’ve heard some complaints from others about the pricing that John offers at his firm but I can’t complain about them! John Miller Carroll DELIVERS RESULTS, IT IS SKILL NOT LUCK!! You are paying for years of Experience and Positive Results! I highly recommend retaining John Miller Carroll for any legal needs! Thank you for everything you’ve helped me with John. - Zachary Schulz

Kaylee MartinLocal Guide4 photos
1 years ago

He’s never prepared, his facts are mixed up & wrong, & he seems money hungry. I don’t know how he’s still getting business. Thankfully the person who was facing 10 yrs in prison, had such an understanding, fair, judge Yadira Rein. Without her as the judge I think she’d be going to prison due to John’s lazy job as a paid lawyer!

Mike Werth
1 years ago

Didn't fight to get less time for revocation or OWI5. Didn't try to pled my time down at all. Hardly talked to between in person or on the phone. Shows up late for court. Didn't get me a plea deal with DA. Just didn't put no effort into my case at all. Will not recommend to anyone. Plus my wife tried to ask a question why my fine is showing at 1270. When the judge said 1000 and all he says she went very low. Didn't fight to get me any credit for time I sat before revocated on another case. For the kind of money paid it was a waist amd wish we could have hired someone else.

Molly Wickham
1 years ago
Molly Wickham
1 years ago

John Miller Carroll is by far the BEST attorney I've EVER had! I can't thank Attorney Carroll enough for his incredible work on my cases. He's professional, knowledgeable, and truly dedicated to achieving the best outcome for me. He took the time to explain everything in detail, kept me informed throughout the process, and fought tirelessly on my behalf. His expertise and strategic approach made a HUGE difference, and I felt the utmost confidence knowing I had such a strong advocate in my corner. He's literally the ONLY attorney I trust to hire and he is worth every dollar! He will fight his absolute hardest to ensure the best outcome possible pertaining to your case. Honestly, I cannot begin to express how much I have to thank Attorney Carrol for my freedom and my life. If you need an attorney who is compassionate and a fierce advocate in the courtroom, I highly recommend him. I will always be grateful! Thank you for everything!

Shannon Rolfe
1 years ago

The best attorney hands down. I’ve retained him for a criminal matter and my personal injury when I got hit by a drunk driver on a snowmobile. Huge settlement. Good communication and office manager jami is a gem! We have become like family working with them the past 8 years.

Bobby Boushay
1 years ago

Owi dismissed! I dont care what anyone says he’s my go to man! He is aggressive, yes, but it’s a good thing, you should see the man in court. I will always be using Jmc law for any future court needs.

Carpe Clean 2 Cleaning Goddesses (Cleaning Goddesses)
1 years ago

Very nice office staff, as well as the manager, atty Carroll took care of my traffic matters promptly he saved license and no points. I use my vehicle daily for my job so this was a huge thing for me.

Jaime Farmer
1 years ago

Do NOT hire him he lies! He tells you what you want to hear and does NOTHING to help you with your case! He will definitely take your money tho

Bryce Carroll
1 years ago
Johnny Johnson
1 years ago

Best lawyer hands down had a police battery which was a felony he got it dropped even though the state was on bs … Best lawyer who gone get the job done highly recommended don’t believe the bad reviews it’s nonsense if he can help he will

Response from owner

Thank you Johnny for your feedback! We are glad we were able to help you with this.

Kimberly Bruneau
1 years ago
G J
2 years ago

Straight trash. All of his bad reviews are true and accurate. Gets his facts mixed up. Money hungry. He'll miss court dates and the judge will have their assistant try and find where he's at. I wish I would've read his reviews before i retained him. Money down the drain

Response from owner

Hello Sam,<br><br>We do not have any one under the name “Sam Kalipickus” in our client database. Would you please post your WI state case number so that we can better assist you.

Brian Beej JentzLocal Guide
2 years ago

Horrible attorney! Charged me a ton to take a case to trial and quit responding to me and took a plea without my consent. I fired him and he would not return my trial fee. Do not trust him! He comes across as professional but will hang you out to dry! I hired another attorney and won my case.

Zach SmithLocal Guide7 photos
2 years ago

reached out when i left a message. overall he gave me really good advice. very friendly and attentive

Response from owner

Thank you for your feedback Zach!

Ariel Fritche
2 years ago

Very rude, claims he can’t read

Michele Van RossumLocal Guide10 photos
2 years ago
Response from owner

Thank you for your review Michele!

KEN9895Local Guide7 photos
2 years ago

Contact

Address
226 S State St, Appleton, WI 54911

Google Profile

Rating
3.6 / 5
Reviews
67
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
7

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code