McCarty Law LLP

region, WI

74
Attorney Index
20 reviews
4.2
Google Rating
70 reviews
McCarty Law LLP

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

Law firm

Review Snapshot

20
Total Reviews
Moderate Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
40%
Response Rate
Somewhat Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 86/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication90
Outcome88
Responsiveness89
Empathy91
Expertise86
Fee Transparency79
Trial Experience81
Satisfaction84

Client Reviews

Tricia Van HandelLocal Guide
6 months ago
Garry Noe
10 months ago

Excellent!

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!<br>

Tyler CormicanLocal Guide1 photo
11 months ago

These people have absolutely no respect for someone else’s time. I had a conversation and gave an explanation and details of the situation that we are in, and I was told that someone would be reaching out to me a few days later and letting me know if this is something that we would be willing to fight or not. After waiting a few days for a phone call, someone reached out and had me provide the same exact information that I already provided two days prior and then they proceed to tell me that there’s nothing that they’re able to do for us until we sign an engagement letter and make a payment to them Which is exactly the opposite of what I was told. Complete waste of time, highly not recommended!

Response from owner

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience; your feedback is important to us and has been shared with our team.

Wes MertzLocal Guide
1 years ago

This was our visit to McCartly law, and we found it to be very welcoming. John Fisher was on top of everything after reviewing all the information we provided prior to our visit. Very friendly and fully ready to help us to update our previous estate submission from Florida to rless under Wisconsin laws

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!<br>

Nancy DeDeckerLocal Guide
1 years ago

I have seen Jon Fischer for 4yrs now. He is wonderful, kind, smart, knowledgeable. Nice staff. Great parking.easy access. I would highly recommend Jon !!!

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!<br>

Brian WruckLocal Guide321 photos
1 years ago
Linda SchrageLocal Guide4 photos
1 years ago

Great people. Donna is amazing.

Alicia Ratajczak1 photo
1 years ago
janeine cardin
1 years ago

Do not use this firm for a probate case extremely undermining /misleading communication with the beneficiaries. Narcissistic even . Gives out contacts early explaining contact me with any questions. Then disappear s leaves beneficiaries calling with reasonable questions not explained eating up costs intentionally. Simple explanation at first letter could occur but does not. Do not use Sara Micheletti or this firm . So overtly dishonest. This probate is current. Fred Cardin dies with no will thus no list of his assets exists. The date of the hearing for the assets inventory is 5 /5 /25 . . Jan Fuller is the contact. Let people know that date. They are not doing that. They do not care nor will they change. Please never use this firm. The 1st warning is read their bios . Generations of lawyers of the firm being there. That means nothing to skill set of communicating efficiently. Total arrogance.

Response from owner

Thank you for your feedback. We are committed to excellent service and appreciate all insights about our interactions.

Patty Payette
1 years ago

Excellent service. Very knowledgeable, professional staff. Great experience.

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!

Jason Lorge
1 years ago

If you want to be talked down to and like condescending attitude, they are for you. If you want them to tell you how much they charge like you can’t afford them, they are for you. If you want someone to say they don’t believe medical bills cost THAT much, they are for you. If you want them to tell you they can’t make money appear even though that’s not why you are calling, they are for you. If you want them to tell you how awesome they are because they charge $350 an hour, as if that’s impressive, they are for you

Response from owner

Thank you for your feedback. We are committed to excellent service and appreciate all insights about our interactions.

D MatushakLocal Guide
1 years ago
Matthew Scheske
2 years ago

McCarty has done tremendous work! I would recommend them without reservation for all of the services they provide.

Keith HinzLocal Guide116 photos
2 years ago

Fair price for a will

Chad RooversLocal Guide1 photo
2 years ago

Reg and his team are incredible! Extremely well educated with the law and helped our family establish a solid estate plan.

Carla Zacharias
2 years ago

Sarah was very knowledgeable and courteous.

Response from owner

We appreciate your feedback! Thank you for taking the time to leave a review!

Donna Floyd4 photos
2 years ago
Dennis Wied1 photo
2 years ago

I was foreclosed on and went to McCarty law firm, Appleton Wi..They needed $450 down and the attorney we worked with said he would talk to his colleagues. We had another appointment to see what they figured out. Well they didn’t figure nothing out and they needed another $250 to continue! Not to mention the cost of the consultation! In the end they said there was nothing they could do! What I know, there was nothing they could do to save my home and they new it! What a joke! Another self centered firm feeding on someone emotions and hard luck! May you burn in Hell! Dennis Wied

William.d RiveraLocal Guide
2 years ago
Mohamed Zakarya
3 years ago

Office was suggested on a list on attorneys through my work that offers legal benefits through MetLife legal plans. Amy took my call, sounded in a hurry and didn’t have the time to listen well. She obviously didn’t know or didn’t give herself the chance to know what MetLife legal service is. She didn’t seem interested in conducting business lol, but I don’t know why not say that straightforward. Regardless, I didn’t expect a call back, and I was right! I let my legal plans team at work remove this office from their recommendation list. Thankfully, I got the advice I needed through a different office.

Contact

Address
2401 E Enterprise Ave, Appleton, WI 54913

Google Profile

Rating
4.2 / 5
Reviews
70
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
3

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code