Michael J. Upton, Attorney at Law

Tuscaloosa, AL

82
Attorney Index
50 reviews
4.8
Google Rating
111 reviews
Michael J. Upton, Attorney at Law

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

Personal injury attorneyLaw firmCriminal justice attorney

Review Snapshot

50
Total Reviews
High Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
65%
Response Rate
Somewhat Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 98/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication100
Outcome100
Responsiveness100
Empathy100
Expertise100
Fee Transparency91
Trial Experience93
Satisfaction96

Client Reviews

gary wood
3 months ago

Had a great attitude, I felt he was actually listening to my case. He told me what the outcomes looked like and I got exactly what I was looking for case dismissed! Excellent Job!!! Would recommend to anyone.

Alvin Beal1 photo
7 months ago

I can’t thank Attorney Michael J. Upton enough for helping me win my case! He was supportive, professional, and always kept me informed. Five stars all the way—highly recommend!

Olivia Acoff
7 months ago

Attorney Michael J. Upton is an outstanding lawyer! He worked tirelessly on my case and got the results I needed. Highly recommend him for anyone looking for strong, honest, and effective representation. You are awesome.

Rachel Shepherd
8 months ago

Hiring Attorney Michael J. Upton has been one of the most disappointing and unprofessional experiences I’ve ever had. I paid him $10,000 in late July 2025 for what he described as a “pre-warrant investigation.” He was involved for only about two months — from late July through early September 2025 — before I terminated his services due to lack of progress and professionalism. During that entire time, there was never a warrant, no arrest, no indictment, and no formal charge ever filed. Despite that, Mr. Upton has kept every dollar of the $10,000 I paid him. From the start, I struggled to get basic communication or updates. When I reached out for information, instead of professionalism, I received demeaning and disrespectful text messages. His tone was rude, condescending, and completely unprofessional — this occurred while he was still representing my son, simply because I was asking for updates. His messages felt bullying and dismissive, especially considering that we were a family under immense stress. When I later asked for a refund, he refused. He eventually offered a partial refund only if I agreed not to file a grievance or lawsuit — which I refused. His justification for keeping the money was that “anything could happen even five years down the line.” So apparently, he believes he can hold a client’s money indefinitely, even though my son has already met with law enforcement. Out of disbelief, I contacted the Alabama State Bar and obtained his official disciplinary record. The records confirm that Mr. Upton has multiple prior reprimands — both public and private — for professional misconduct, including issues involving client communication, excessive fees, and mishandling of client matters. These are official Bar documents, available to anyone who requests them directly from the Alabama State Bar. My experience mirrors the same pattern seen in those reprimands: poor communication, lack of accountability, and disregard for clients. I feel deceived, bullied, and completely disappointed. If you value honesty, transparency, and professionalism, I strongly urge you to look elsewhere. I regret ever trusting him with my family’s case, our money, or our peace of mind.

Ashton Yarboro
8 months ago

Great and affordable attorney that will actually listen to your case. Very professional lawyer, would definitely recommend

Response from owner

Ashton, you were a fantastic client to work with and I'm glad I could get you a great outcome! You and my other 105 Five Star Reviews are much appreciated!<br><br>Thanks, Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

A LLocal Guide1 photo
8 months ago

I feel compelled to share my disturbing experience with Michael Upton, to caution others, particularly women who might consider working with him. My interactions with him left me deeply concerned about his conduct and professionalism. Michael’s comments and demeanor made me feel uncomfortable and disrespected, creating an environment that felt unsafe. This was not an isolated incident but a consistent pattern that raised serious red flags about his character and suitability as a legal professional. His communication style was aggressive and, at times, threatening. Instead of fostering a sense of trust or respect, he used intimidation tactics that were entirely uncalled for. This behavior made it clear that he lacks the temperament required to represent clients effectively or ethically. For someone in the field of criminal justice, where respect for others is critical, these traits were alarming and undermined any confidence I might have had in his abilities. I strongly urge potential clients, especially women, to exercise caution when considering Michael Upton. Legal professionals should inspire trust, respect, and confidence, but my experience with him was the opposite. I recommend looking for an attorney who demonstrates professionalism and treats all individuals with the respect they deserve.

Response from owner

This is the same regurgitated lies by Rachel Shepherd, either anonymously by her, or anonymously by someone else on her behalf. "Anonymous" reviews are from gutless people like this. <br><br>Go public with your name and contact information! Otherwise people should just ignore an anonymous liar.<br><br>This person has filed 14 reviews, ALL ONE STAR REVIEWS! Haha<br><br>I wonder who the problem really is!<br><br>I have 105 FIVE STAR REVIEWS. All those 105 people know the deal 😎

Cade Randolph
8 months ago

Great man very kind and helpful

Response from owner

Thanks Cade!

Lilly Werling
9 months ago
Response from owner

Thank you!

Definitely not Potatoes
9 months ago
Samantha Currie
9 months ago
khloe
9 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Savannah Thursby
9 months ago
Mia Harbison
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

gabrielle kornyik
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks! 🙂<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Matt K
10 months ago

Mr Upton is an incredible attorney, he is a great communicator and always on top of his work. He helped me with my case and kept me in the loop every step of the way. Can’t recommend him enough.

Response from owner

Thanks! Glad to help!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Riley Hall
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks! Glad to help!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Kendall Rice
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Alyssa Mcgirt
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Taylor Williams
10 months ago
Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Tara Glass1 photo
10 months ago

Recommended by a friend and very helpful! Highly recommend!

Response from owner

Thanks!<br>Michael Upton uptonlawyer.com

Contact

Address
410 20th Ave, Tuscaloosa, AL 35401

Google Profile

Rating
4.8 / 5
Reviews
111
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
12

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code