O'Malley Law Office, P.C.

Fort Collins, CO

52
Attorney Index
50 reviews
-
Google Rating
68 reviews

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Review Snapshot

50
Total Reviews
High Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
0%
Response Rate
Low Response
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 59/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication60
Outcome60
Responsiveness60
Empathy60
Expertise60
Fee Transparency55
Trial Experience57
Satisfaction60

Client Reviews

Matthew Evans
6 months ago

Worked with Matt Martorella regarding my daughter's case in Ft. Collins, 2025-26. Very professional work, always explaining to me on a level that I could understand, always working to get the lesser charge, and always had my daughter's best interest at heart! Really cared and expressed his concerns, 100% honest to me all the time. Would go back to Matt for anything that comes up in the future... 100/100 times!!! Thank you for everything you did for our daughter, & our family! Much appreciated!

Marie Tougas
8 months ago

Kelsey helped me with my case and After 6 months it was dismissed. Great lawyer and my experience was Awesome.

srinivas vellappan1 photo
8 months ago

Kelsey Leck was amazing to work with. She was very positive, and clear in her approach and supportive from the very beginning, which made a stressful situation much easier to handle. I always felt comfortable working with her, as she was very approachable, patient, and responsive at every step. She always took the time to explain things clearly and made me feel confident. I truly felt that she cared about my case. I highly recommend her.

C W
8 months ago

When you are from out of Colorado with no idea how to get the help you need where do you turn. I reached out to O'Malley Law Office and Attorney Kelsey Leck took up my case meeting with me online while I was in my home state making sure I understood what was happening every step of the way. Kelsey made sure my in person hearing was moved to a on line venue saving me a plane flight to Colorado. Kelsey gave me great advice on what to present in my defense. Kelsey gave me great news that after the District Attorney looked at my case he moved to dismiss. What a Christmas present!! I would recommend Attorney Kelsey Keck. Thanks to the staff for connecting me to Kelsey promptly every time,

Evo Davila
8 months ago

I can’t say enough good things about Kelsey Leck. She guided me through my case with absolute professionalism, kindness, and confidence. She explained every step clearly, always responded quickly, and fought for me from day one. Thanks to her, we won my uphill battle kind of case. I felt supported the entire way. I highly recommend her to anyone who needs an attorney who genuinely cares.

Luiza Franco
8 months ago

I had an excellent experience with Kelsey one of the sweetest attorney! You can trust them! I win my case with her!

john abeare
9 months ago

I want to Premise this approval review by saying that I’m not the type of person that ever leaves a review but I think it’s very important for people that have found themselves caught in a legal system to have the best information possible. I was in a situation where I was looking at a deal for close to eight years, negotiated by the public defender in Larimer county. I was told this deal was the best that I was gonna get and I needed to wrap my head around it. All that Change once I hired Matthew Martorella (former prosecutor)with O’Malley law! Upon hiring Matt that 8 year life changing deal was immediately off the table! Long story short I was back in my home working with an eight and a half months!!! I also can’t Express how happy I was with the amount of communication and energy that was put into my case. Matt would call me sometimes twice a week if nothing else just to check on me and my mental health when dealing with the court system. Court dates never pushed for attorney reasons and Mr.O'Malley himself stepped in, well informed of my case, to fill in at one hearing as well! And anybody that’s ever dealt with the court system knows that you can lose months of your life when dates get pushed back!! I can’t say how incredibly pleased I am with Matthew Martorella at O’Malley Law

Cody Solis
9 months ago

I had a great experience with Kelsey, she was very kind, knowledgeable and was great with communication. She made the legal process less daunting and helped me get my case resolved in my favor. I highly recommend this law firm/ Kelsey if you need solid representation.

Kaitlyn ParkerLocal Guide
10 months ago

I cannot recommend Kelsey highly enough. From the very beginning, she showed incredible attention to detail and a deep understanding of my case. She took the time to listen, explain every step clearly, and made sure I always felt informed and supported. What stood out most was her genuine care for my wellbeing — not just as a client, but as a person. Kelsey was patient, compassionate, and truly invested in achieving the best possible outcome. She never backed down when things got difficult and fought tirelessly to ensure justice was served. Her professionalism, knowledge, and calm confidence made all the difference. Thanks to her skill and dedication, my case was resolved favorably without unnecessary stress or escalation. Kelsey is the kind of attorney who goes above and beyond, combining sharp legal expertise with sincere empathy. If you’re looking for someone who will advocate fiercely while keeping your best interests at heart, Kelsey is the lawyer you want by your side. Thank you Kelsey.

Sage Ann1 photo
11 months ago

To say the least.. Matt is the best attorney I could have asked for. From the start he took his time to look over everything with meticulous attention for detail. He was patient and kind and really heard me out at my consultation. Immediately Matt was smart and diligent in his approach to my case. I was kept in the loop the entire time, and he always responded to me in a timely manner. Matt was honest about expectations and nothing short of an amazing advocate for me. He was able to get me a dismissal and I can’t thank him enough. Highly recommend him, he’s a very smart attorney!

Liz Valdez
1 years ago

I thank God for finding this office. Staff and Lawyer Terry O'Malley have been honest and so helpful during difficult times. Terry represented my husband with honesty and he truly showed he cared for our family's wellbeing. God bless you.

Sue Knaus
1 years ago

We found Matt Martorella at O'Malley Law Office in Fort Collins to be very competent and thorough. He worked hard to get our case resolved in a timely manner. Matt was effective, compassionate and used high expertise. While we don't want to have more legal issues, if they did arise we would be quick to call on Matt. Sue Knaus

Patil Sds
1 years ago

I had an excellent experience working with Kelsey as my lawyer. She was not only professional and knowledgeable, but also genuinely caring and attentive throughout my case. Kelsey took the time to explain each step of the process clearly, always answered my questions promptly, and made me feel confident and supported. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, my legal issue was resolved smoothly and efficiently. I highly recommend Kelsey to anyone seeking legal help—you’ll be in great hands!

tyler hessLocal Guide18 photos
1 years ago

Reached out via website, I also reached out via calling the office - requested to speak to a lawyer regarding some help with a few things. Needless to say it’s been 1 1/2 days since the phone call(I made) - and about 3 days since the website attempt - the women took my name and number over the phone - if this is the way you conduct your business I will be looking somewhere else - a polite and simple call back from the office would be acceptable, just saying that everyone is very busy and sorry for the delay. Again this shows me how much you want my business and the way you probably treat clients. I feel like a firm should probably be trying to get peoples business not ignoring it. Thanks for nothing

sean betz
1 years ago

Terry O’Malley and his secretary are nothing short of amazing. I was facing a difficult situation, and I gave Terry a call. He was able to help me navigate the legal system with ease. This man knows what he is doing! When he wasn’t able to answer the phone his secretary was there to answer any questions I had quickly. We were able to end my tough situation with an ideal outcome thanks to Terry. He even went out of his way to deal with the pretrial officer on my behalf multiple times due to errors they had made. If I ever need help navigating the legal system again, I will definitely be contacting O’Malley Law Office again. Thank you O’Malley Law Office!

Dane Anderson2 photos
1 years ago

Incredible law firm - Matthew Martorella is your guy. I ran into trouble in Fort Collins and my long gone past from 15 years ago haunted me on a third charge. I was facing incarceration and on the verge of losing my very high paying career that I moved out here for because I was previously unaware of the strict laws that Colorado has. I made the ultimate mistake. I work up in Nebraska - Matt called every county within 75 miles of my work and no district offered a work release program. He dug through the law and found a way to get me work release - He then traveled out to Logan County Colorado 2 hours away where I live and met with a halfway house coordinator and set it all up. All I had to do was pay and serve 90 days and I could keep my career and my life in tact. I also only received a DWAI - and just 1 year of supervised probation. I’ve worked with many lawyers, including extremely prestigious lawyers in Illinois and nobody came close to the professionalism that - Matt alone - brought to the table. Matt has a huge future and will succeed greatly with law. Future candidate for the President of the Larimer County Bar association one day. He even unexpectedly answered the phone at the office late on a Friday. Couldn’t believe it. He is a natural at this and has passion.

Gator
1 years ago

Terry is a precise, prompt and an informative lawyer. He knows what he is doing and will help you achieve the best results in your case. He is also fair in his fees.

Max Smith
2 years ago

Matthew Martorella certainly went above and beyond to communicate with me, set realistic expectations, and executed on any requests that I had. I have dealt with several lawyers over the years and he was by far the best I could have chosen.

Robin Bracy4 photos
2 years ago

Matthew Martorella is a smart lawyer that will 'take care of you!' I would highly recommend him if you need an attorney that knows the law in-and-out and gets results. He is respectable and professional.

Hayes Faulkenberry
2 years ago

Great experience. If you are on the fence please go with O’Malley. Matthew went above and beyond and was always available when I had questions. Also very affordable compared to some of the other lawyers that I spoke with

Contact

Google Profile

Reviews
68
Claimed
No

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code