Old City Law

St. Augustine, FL

82
Attorney Index
27 reviews
4.9
Google Rating
27 reviews
Old City Law

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

AttorneyCivil law attorneyEstate planning attorneyLaw firmReal estate attorneyTitle company

Review Snapshot

27
Total Reviews
Moderate Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
50%
Response Rate
Somewhat Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 98/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication100
Outcome100
Responsiveness100
Empathy100
Expertise100
Fee Transparency93
Trial Experience95
Satisfaction98

Client Reviews

Nik PatelLocal Guide5 photos
4 months ago

Outstanding attorney with deep expertise in business law and contract disputes. Professional, responsive, and strategic from start to finish. If you need a skilled trial lawyer who delivers results and clear communication, this law firm is the one to hire. Highly recommend for legal representation.

denita kittoLocal Guide20 photos
7 months ago

Outstanding law office! We have used Anish and his staff on several occasions for property closings , estate and trust planning, as our business attorney , and more. We would recommend him and his office to anyone needing an excellent attorney and a professional staff and office . Ceres , his assistant is also top notch !!

Freddy UnderhillLocal Guide292 photos
7 months ago

Anish Patel is the real deal. A man with a big heart and will stand up for what's right. I am incredibly thankful to have him on our side.

Response from owner

Freddy, thank you so much for your kind words and for taking the time to share your experience!<br>We’re truly honored to have earned your trust, and it means the world to hear that Anish’s dedication, respect, and care has been at his forefront in assisting you. He’s passionate about standing up for what’s right, and reviews like yours remind us why we do what we do every single day.<br>We’re grateful to have the opportunity to represent you. We truly appreciate you taking the time to leave this genuine review.

Frank Perez-AndreuLocal Guide6 photos
11 months ago

We’ve had the pleasure of working with Old City Law and Anish Patel for several years, and they have truly become an integral part of our business. As one of our preferred closing attorneys, Anish and his team consistently deliver exceptional service, no matter the complexity of the transaction. Their professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail are unmatched, and their ability to navigate complicated legal matters has been invaluable to us and our clients. What sets Anish apart is not just his legal expertise, but his commitment to clear communication and client care. He takes the time to explain the process, answer questions thoroughly, and ensure all parties are informed every step of the way. Whether it’s a straightforward closing or a more nuanced issue, we always feel confident with Old City Law at the table. In an industry where precision, timing, and trust matter, Anish and his team have proven to be dependable, knowledgeable, and a true asset. We’re grateful to have them as part of our extended team and highly recommend Old City Law to anyone looking for top-tier legal representation in real estate transactions.

Response from owner

Frank, <br>I personally and on behalf of Old City Law thank you more than this review can express. I am deeply honored by your words and truly grateful for the opportunity to work with you and your exceptional team over the years. Your business is integral to ours as well, and nothing can fully express how much we value our continued relationship. It is a privilege to collaborate with such a professional, capable, and leading team in the real estate industry.<br><br>Your trust in Old City Law and our commitment to delivering exceptional service drives us to maintain the highest standards in every transaction. <br><br>We are humbled by your recognition of our efforts and remain dedicated to providing the clear communication, attention to detail, and client care that you’ve come to expect. Thank you for being an invaluable part of our extended team—we look forward to many more years of partnership and success together. <br><br>Sincerely, <br>Anish Patel and Old City Law

Ron M
11 months ago

Super knowledgeable, responsive and trustworthy

Response from owner

Ron, first and for most, thank you! We’re thrilled to hear that you found our law firm super knowledgeable, responsive, and trustworthy. At Old City Law, our dedicated team strives to provide expert legal guidance with prompt communication and unwavering integrity to ensure the best outcomes for our clients. Your kind words truly motivate us to continue delivering exceptional service. If you need further legal assistance or have questions, we’re here to help. Thanks again for choosing us and sharing your positive experience!

Connie BusheyLocal Guide88 photos
11 months ago

Absolutely nothing but professional and fast service thank you for assisting in my legal needs highly recommend

Response from owner

Connie, We are very appreciative of your review and to hear that you experienced nothing but professional and fast service from Old City Law. We are committed to providing personalized legal assistance with efficiency and care to meet your needs. Your recommendation means the world to us, and we’re here for any future legal support you may require. Thanks again for choosing us and sharing your positive feedback!

Ro MaLocal Guide69 photos
12 months ago

Old City Law provided us with exceptional legal service at a highly competitive cost. We recommend this firm well above other ones we consulted.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your thoughtful review! We’re truly grateful you chose Old City Law and are thrilled to hear that your experience stood out among other firms. Providing high-quality legal service at a fair and transparent cost is something we take great pride in, and it means a lot to know you felt supported and well-represented throughout the process. Your recommendation means the world to us. If you ever need anything in the future, we’re always here to help.<br><br>— The Old City Law Team

Wylie UtkeLocal Guide
1 years ago

I have been using Old City Law for a couple years now and their team has been an amazing help for several stressful situations I've had to go through. I don't think I could ask for more.

Response from owner

Wylie, Thank you so much for your continued trust and kind words! It truly means a lot to us that you’ve chosen Old City Law to stand by your side through some of life’s more stressful moments. We’re honored to have been able to support you over the years and are always here when you need us. Helping good people navigate tough situations is exactly why we do what we do. Your loyalty and appreciation genuinely motivates our firm's passion for excellence.<br><br>- The Old City Law Team

Josh SmithLocal Guide2 photos
1 years ago

I’m currently going through a renting issue that I need legal advice on and wanted to weigh options to see if I needed to move to a legal dispute down the road. I called this law office because of their great reviews and their website says they handle these types of issues. I called and spoke to an assistant and after explaining the situation, she put me on hold to speak with someone and came back with “they’re not taking on new clients” and also, “they’re not equipped to handle this issue right now”. When I asked if I could pay for an hour to get some direction on the situation as I wasn’t sure if this is even something I would immediately become a client for, I was put on hold for the 3rd time for around 15-20 minutes and I hung up at that point. I’m a local business owner. I mentioned this because I saw they did contractual work and I may want to use their services since my business is expanding. I don’t know who the assistant was speaking to off the phone but if it was the owner of this firm: Do better. Very short sighted business practices. The assistant at least was trying to refer me to other firms via Google search. I appreciate the effort on her part as she obviously was not getting help from the team. The 15-20 minute hold was the last straw and why I’m writing this review. Thanks for wasting my time. Won’t be recommending to anyone.

Response from owner

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your frustrating experience when contacting Old City Law. We take pride in our commitment to exceptional client service, and we regret that we couldn’t meet your expectations during your call. After reviewing our records, it appears you were not a client, and we understand you’ve shared similar concerns about other firms regarding the same matter. Our team strives to provide accurate guidance, and in some cases, we may not be able to take on new matters due to current caseloads or specialization, which our staff communicates transparently. We’re grateful for our assistant’s efforts to assist you by suggesting alternative resources, and we apologize for any extended hold times, which are not reflective of our usual standards. Old City Law is dedicated to professional, timely service for our clients’ legal needs. We invite you to reach out directly to discuss how we can better assist you or provide referrals tailored to your situation. Thank you for your understanding, and we wish you the best in resolving your matter.

Jonathan Mateer
1 years ago

I cannot say enough positive things about my experience with Old City Law. They were knowledgeable, kind, and genuinely listened to my thoughts and concerns throughout the entire process.

Response from owner

Hi Jonathan,<br>Thank you for the wonderful review! We’re so glad to hear that you had a positive experience with Old City Law. Providing knowledgeable and compassionate service while truly listening to our clients is something we’re passionate about, and it’s great to know we were able to meet your expectations. We appreciate your trust and positive feedback!<br>Thank you, <br>Old City Law

David OrrLocal Guide7 photos
2 years ago

Mr. Patel and his team clearly care about their clients and are highly effective at resolving their issues. There are a lot of law firms out there who seem to only care about making a buck, but Old City Law is one of the rare ones that put their clients’ needs above their own. Can’t recommend them enough!

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your kind words! We truly appreciate your feedback and are grateful for the opportunity to assist you. At Old City Law, our primary focus has always been to provide dedicated, client-centered service. We're thrilled to hear that you felt supported and that we were able to resolve your issues effectively. It's incredibly rewarding to know that our efforts to prioritize our clients’ needs are being recognized. Mr. Patel and the entire team are passionate about helping people and ensuring they receive the best possible legal representation. Your recommendation means the world to us, and we will continue to work hard to live up to the trust you've placed in us. Thanks again for taking the time to share your experience, and please don’t hesitate to reach out if you ever need further assistance in the future!

Rebecca Smith
2 years ago

Attorney Anish Patel was courteous, responsive & knowledgeable in regards to our needs and his firm. Appreciate all he did for us during his time of representation! Thank you.

Response from owner

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave such a kind review! It was truly a pleasure to work with you and provide the satisfactory representation you deserved.<br>Your appreciation means the world to us, and we're grateful for the opportunity to assist you.<br>Should you ever require legal assistance in the future or have any questions, please don't hesitate to reach out. We're always here to help.<br>Thank you, <br>Old City Law<br>Anish K. Patel

Jay Carter Martin1 photo
3 years ago

I high recommend Old City Law for any of your business legal needs. They truly care about their clients. I worked with Marcus recently and cannot say enough positive things about my experience. He took the time to educate and communicate all the details to me to make sure I understood everything. He even went out of his way to make sure he completed some documents that I needed a fast turnaround on. If you need some legal help with your business, Old City Law is the best in the city! I will definitely be working with them again.

Doug Hart
3 years ago

We have worked with Marcus at Old City Law on two projects to date and were very satisfied. They are to be recommended.

Sid MicklerLocal Guide1349 photos
3 years ago

So glad I chose this firm after another lawyer recommended them to me . It took a few days for them to get to me , but we're talking real estate in St. John's County , lol . Marcus was great , answered my questions and advised me on how to move forward on my project . I will definitely use them in the future !

Paul Maass
4 years ago

Old City Law goes above in beyond in every facet of how they operate their business. For my business, Anish has always responded in a timely fashion and handled all of STA Trivia's contractual requirements flawlessly and with ease. As a personal attorney, Marcus also went above and beyond by handling all of my legal needs with the utmost professionalism and diligent care. Old City Law is the most prestigious up and coming law firm in northeast Florida, and will be making a very positive impact on their community for many years to come.

Stetson ShannonLocal Guide14 photos
4 years ago

They fight tooth and nail for you . I recommend that you give them a call and schedule a appointment definitely worth the money.

Ron WarrenLocal Guide249 photos
4 years ago

I had a commercial tenant payment issue. Anish Patel got on it immediately reaching out to the employer and tenant. The situation was resolved amicably shortly thereafter.

JD Patel
4 years ago

Anish was an outstanding lawyer and very professional throughout this entire process. He made himself available whenever we needed without hesitation. His quality of work and dedication to helping us get the best deal/outcome is what makes him the successful lawyer that he is. He always had our best interests in mind and I never second guessed his opinions. I would absolutely recommend to everyone and will be using him again in the future without a doubt.

Kelly Papineau
4 years ago

The most professional and honestly good people I’ve ever had the pleasure of dealing with. Anish went way above and beyond to help me. I can’t say enough great things about this firm. Highly recommended!

Contact

Address
1 Riberia St, St. Augustine, FL 32084

Google Profile

Rating
4.9 / 5
Reviews
27
Status
Close
Claimed
Yes
Photos
7

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code