Piscitelli Law Firm - Injury & Car Accident Lawyer

region, OH

85
Attorney Index
20 reviews
4.9
Google Rating
63 reviews
Piscitelli Law Firm - Injury & Car Accident Lawyer

Practice Areas

Personal InjuryCar Accident

Business Profile

Personal injury attorneyLaw firmAttorneyLegal servicesTrial attorney

Review Snapshot

20
Total Reviews
Moderate Confidence
2
Last 90 Days
Moderate
100%
Response Rate
Highly Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 98/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication100
Outcome100
Responsiveness100
Empathy100
Expertise100
Fee Transparency93
Trial Experience95
Satisfaction98

Client Reviews

Kim RollysonLocal Guide2 photos
2 months ago

Frank is a caring, concerned and honest attorney. He will fight for you and get you everything he can and and that you deserve. He is always there for you, willing to listen and help any way he can. You have the best with Frank on your side. Trust me, I was there in 2017, in a 6 car crash in Elyria and Frank was by my side the whole way. Thanks again Frank. Sincerely, Kim R.

Response from owner

Thank you so much, Kim. Your message truly means a great deal. We’re so glad Frank was able to stand by your side after such a serious six-car accident and provide the support and advocacy you needed. His commitment to listening, fighting hard, and being present for his clients is exactly what we strive for at The Piscitelli Law Firm. We’re grateful for your trust, then and now, and wish you all the very best.

Linda Miller
2 months ago

THE PISCITELLI LAW FIRM DID AN EXCELLENT JOB OF HANDLING MY PERSONAL INJURY LAWSUIT RESULTING FROM A CAR ACCIDENT. I CHOSE THEM BECAUSE THEY ARE CONVENIENTLY LOCATED IN LAKE COUNTY AND THEY DON’T DO ALL THE ADVERTISING LIKE OTHER FIRMS DO. I FOUND MR PISCITELLI AND HIS STAFF TO BE VERY DEDICATED AND HELPFUL. THEY ANSWERED MY QUESTIONS AND PROMPTLY RETURNED MY CALLS. AS A RESULT OF THEIR EFFORTS, I WAS ABLE TO RECEIVE A SETTLEMENT THAT WAS MORE THAN I HAD ANTICIPATED.

Response from owner

Thank you so much, Linda! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. It means a great deal that you chose The Piscitelli Law Firm and found our team dedicated, responsive, and helpful throughout your personal injury case. We’re especially glad we could exceed your expectations with the outcome. Your trust and kind words mean everything to us!

Bailey Celeste
3 months ago

I had never been in a car accident before and had never worked with an attorney, so I didn’t know what to expect going into this. What I thought would be a stressful, confusing process ended up being incredibly easy thanks to Frank Piscitelli. From the start, Frank handled everything with confidence and clarity. Any time I had a question, he gave me detailed answers that actually made sense. I never felt lost or unsure of what was happening. His communication was consistent, and he kept me updated every step of the way without me ever having to ask. What impressed me most was how well he knew my case. It never felt like I was just another file on his desk — he remembered every detail, every update, and every conversation. That level of attention made me feel genuinely supported and reassured throughout the entire process. Frank went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled smoothly, and he made a difficult situation so much easier to navigate. If you’re looking for an accident attorney who is knowledgeable, responsive, and truly invested in getting you the best outcome, I can’t recommend Frank Piscitelli enough. He exceeded every expectation I had.

Response from owner

Thanks so much, Bailey! That kind of thoughtful feedback means a lot. Frank puts real care into every case, and it’s great to hear that it made your first experience with a lawyer feel clear and manageable. We're glad you felt supported through it all. Please reach out to us if you need anything!

John PilcherLocal Guide1 photo
3 months ago

William Macadam is unfortunately extremely rude but otherwise, no complaints.

Response from owner

William Macadam has not worked for our law firm in more than 9 years. He has had no association with the Piscitelli Law Firm since 2017. His Facebook comments do not reflect the opinions of our law firm. Please remove your review, as it has a massive negative impact on our law firm - a small, locally owned business that was established to help represent injured people of Ohio.

Nicole Matejka
3 months ago
Response from owner

Thank you for the 5-star review, Nicole! We really appreciate it.

Michelle Piscitelli
3 months ago

Frank has provided excellent guidance whenever I have sought his advice. He takes the time to thoroughly understand your questions before responding. Frank is knowledgeable in his field, and if your needs fall outside his area of expertise, he will recommend someone who can assist you appropriately.

Response from owner

Thank you, Michelle! Your words are a wonderful reflection of the care and professionalism Frank brings to every interaction. Taking the time to fully understand each situation and provide thoughtful, informed guidance is exactly the kind of support we strive to offer at The Piscitelli Law Firm. We truly appreciate your trust and recommendation!

Frank Cuevas
3 months ago

Frank is a true professional and a great person to work with. As a neighboring business owner, I’ve seen firsthand the integrity and care he brings to his clients. Highly recommend.

Response from owner

Thank you, Frank! We truly appreciate your thoughtful words. It means a great deal coming from a fellow business owner who’s had the opportunity to see Frank’s integrity and care firsthand. At The Piscitelli Law Firm, we take pride in the relationships we build with clients and within our community. Thank you for the recommendation!

Hamady diallo
4 months ago

I’m beyond grateful for the work my lawyer frank Piscitelli did on my case. He was always responsive, honest, and fully committed to getting the best possible outcome for me. You can tell he truly cares about his clients and takes pride in his work. I felt supported and confident every step of the way. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone in need of legal representation.

Response from owner

Thank you, Hamady, for your thoughtful review and kind words. We’re truly glad to hear that you felt supported, informed, and confident throughout your case. Frank and the entire team take great pride in providing responsive, honest representation, and your recommendation means a great deal to us. We sincerely appreciate the trust you placed in Piscitelli Law Firm.

Ellen BrownLocal Guide1 photo
4 months ago

Mr. Piscitelli is very nice, explains things and seems to have his clients best interest.

Response from owner

Ellen, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We’re glad to hear that Mr. Piscitelli was kind, took the time to explain things clearly, and showed genuine care for your best interests. If there’s anything more we could have done to make your experience a five-star one, we’d truly appreciate hearing your feedback. Your input helps us continue to improve and better serve our clients.

Denise Carkhuff
4 months ago

I recommend Frank for any personal injury or wrongful death claim. He brings both experience and passion to his representation. I have referred him to dozens of injured people through the years because I trust that he will get the best result available.

Response from owner

Denise, thank you for such a meaningful review. We truly appreciate your trust in Frank and your confidence in his experience and dedication. It means a great deal to know you’ve referred so many people over the years, and we’re grateful for your continued support of Piscitelli Law Firm.

Missy Ryder
7 months ago

He was very personable. I felt like he treated me like family. Goes above and beyond. Would answer my calls/texts after hours. Would definitely recommend using this lawfirm.

Response from owner

Thank you, Missy! We’re so glad to hear that you felt like family throughout your experience with our firm. Providing personable, accessible, and dedicated legal support is at the core of what we do. Going above and beyond for our clients—whether during business hours or after—is part of the commitment we make every day. We truly appreciate your recommendation!

Christian Mercado1 photo
7 months ago

One of the most passionate caring lawyers in mentor Ohio he’s has tooken on my case and got me the best results ever thank you Frank Piscitelli you’re Awesome!

Response from owner

Thank you, Christian! We're so glad you had such a positive experience. Frank’s passion for helping people and fighting for the best possible outcome is what drives our work every day. It means a lot to hear how much his dedication impacted your case. We truly appreciate your kind words!

Jamie Jonke
7 months ago

Great Attorney very compassionate understanding and always there for you if I needed a lawyer again I will definitely go to them

Response from owner

Thank you, Jamie! We're truly grateful for your kind words. Compassion, understanding, and being available when our clients need us most are the values we live by. We’re honored to know you'd return to us if ever needed again—and we’ll be here when you do.

Peter KolpLocal Guide
7 months ago

Good plaintiff attorney in your area. Good person as well.

Response from owner

Thanks, Peter! We appreciate your kind words. Let us know if you ever need further assistance in the future! Happy to help.

Rhonda Phipps
8 months ago

During one of the most challenging times of my life Frank Piscitelli (Piscitelli Law Firm) proved to be a valuable support that I needed. From the first time I spoke with him, I felt that I had found someone who really cared about me and my situation. He was patient, compassionate and cared about me as a person. He explained everything to me in terms I could easily understand and was always very responsive when I had questions or just needed to talk. His hard work and dedication to my case resulted in a settlement that far exceeded any expectations that I had.

Response from owner

Rhonda, thank you for sharing such a heartfelt review. We’re so glad to hear that Frank was able to provide the patience, compassion, and guidance you needed during such a difficult time. Knowing that he explained everything clearly and was always available for your questions speaks to the care he puts into each client’s case. We’re especially pleased that his dedication led to a settlement that exceeded your expectations. Your trust and kind words mean so much to our team.

Sarah Gray
8 months ago

Frank was helpful and attentive. The advice given was worthwhile, useful, and helped us navigate any future proceedings.

Response from owner

Sarah, thank you so much for sharing your experience! We’re glad to hear that Frank’s attentiveness and thoughtful advice provided clarity and reassurance as you prepared for the future. It’s wonderful to know his guidance made a meaningful impact, and we truly appreciate your trust in our team throughout the process.

Pam Duncan
9 months ago

I really enjoyed talking to this attorney I would recommend him

Response from owner

Thank you, Pam! We're glad to hear you had a great experience speaking with Frank. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we're grateful for your kind words!

Gina
9 months ago

can’t say enough good things about my experience with Frank Pescitelli and their team. Over the past year, they supported me through one of the most stressful times in my life with patience, professionalism, and genuine care. They always took the time to explain things clearly, kept me informed, and made sure I never felt alone in the process. I’m beyond grateful for their dedication and hard work. You can tell they truly care about the people they help—not just the case. I’ll never forget how much this meant to me, and I’d recommend them to anyone needing someone strong, honest, and compassionate on their side.

Response from owner

Thank you, Gina. Your words mean so much to all of us at The Piscitelli Law Firm. We’re truly honored to have supported you during such a difficult time, and we're grateful that Frank and the team could provide not just legal guidance but genuine care throughout the process. Your trust, appreciation, and heartfelt recommendation are deeply valued. We wish you continued strength and all the best ahead.

Kayla Cothran2 photos
9 months ago

I was rear-ended by a drunk driver in a box truck, and Frank Piscitelli was by my side every step of the way. He worked tirelessly for two years to help me get the settlement I deserved. Frank’s communication was excellent, he always took the time to explain everything clearly and kept me informed throughout the entire process. His compassion and genuine care made a difficult situation so much easier. I’m incredibly grateful for his dedication and professionalism I highly recommend!

Response from owner

Thank you so much, Kayla. We're truly grateful for your thoughtful words and are happy we were able to be of assistance through such a challenging experience. Frank’s commitment to clear communication, compassion, and persistence reflects the core of what we strive for at The Piscitelli Law Firm. We’re glad he was able to make a difficult time a bit easier, and your recommendation means the world to us. Wishing you continued healing and all the best as you move forward.

Christy Next Move Cleveland OhioLocal Guide26 photos
9 months ago

I worked with Frank Piscitelli during a challenging time after my daughter's car accident, we were grateful she walked away after this hit and even more happy she was alone in the car. Throughout the process, he was professional and communicated clearly, which helped us navigate a tough situation. While we settled without going to court, I felt that the outcome was satisfactory given the circumstances. I appreciate the support and guidance he provided and I would recommend him for personal injury cases.

Response from owner

Thank you for such a nice review, Christy! We’re so glad your daughter was safe, and we truly appreciate you sharing your experience. Frank’s professionalism and clear communication are a reflection of the care we strive to provide every client, especially during difficult moments. We're grateful you felt supported throughout the process, and your recommendation means a great deal to all of us at The Piscitelli Law Firm.

Contact

Address
7200 Center St Suite 312, Mentor, OH 44060

Google Profile

Rating
4.9 / 5
Reviews
63
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
35

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code