Port City Legal

region, ME

82
Attorney Index
20 reviews
4.8
Google Rating
82 reviews
Port City Legal

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

Business Profile

Family law attorneyEstate planning attorneyProbate attorney

Review Snapshot

20
Total Reviews
Moderate Confidence
0
Last 90 Days
Inactive
100%
Response Rate
Highly Responsive
12-Month Trend
Stable

Review Intelligence

Avg: 98/100
CommunicationOutcomeResponsivenessEmpathyExpertiseFeeTrialSatisfaction
Communication100
Outcome100
Responsiveness100
Empathy100
Expertise100
Fee Transparency91
Trial Experience93
Satisfaction96

Client Reviews

Rina D
3 months ago
Response from owner

Thank you for the support!!!

Vic Graves
3 months ago

Richard is truly the kind of attorney you hope to have in your corner when navigating something as personal and high-stakes as a custody case. He is thoughtful, strategic, and deeply committed to the well-being of the families he represents. Throughout this journey to establish parental rights for my daughter, he consistently demonstrated professionalism, compassion, and an unwavering dedication to doing what was right for our situation. During the court process I was diagnosed with cancer and underwent treatment. Richard and his team went out of their way to check in on me and my daughter every step of the way. I can’t even tell you how much that kindness meant. I also want to give a heartfelt thank you to Erin. From the moment we connected, her kindness and compassion stood out. During such an emotionally heavy process, she was patient, supportive, and always made me feel heard and cared for. The way she approaches her work—with both professionalism and genuine empathy—made an incredibly difficult chapter of my life feel far less overwhelming. Navigating the court system while protecting your child’s future is one of the most stressful experiences a parent can go through. Having a team that truly cares makes all the difference. Richard and Erin provided not only legal expertise but also humanity and support when it mattered most. I am deeply grateful for everything they did for my daughter and me, and I would wholeheartedly recommend this firm to anyone who needs a legal team that combines skill, integrity, and genuine compassion.

Response from owner

We really appreciate your taking the time to post this, and your kind words. It is really gratifying for all of us to help clients who need and benefit from our actions. And I agree - our team is amazing!

Joanna Leary
7 months ago

Maryellen has been amazingly helpful to my brother and I in trying to navigate confusing and urgent legal matters for my aging mom. We suddenly needed to get power of attorney done and Maryellen was able to give us an appointment on very short notice. We went from knowing we needed to get this document done but totally clueless as to how to make that happen to it was done and notarized within four days. I am extremely impressed with how kind and helpful Maryellen is at such a difficult time for our family. Fast forward almost two years and Maryellen is STILL helping out. We have a few final details to iron out and Maryellen responded to my questions as quickly as if I was a highly lucrative client. If you have any legal needs, Maryellen will help you out.

Response from owner

Joanna, thank you so much for taking the time to leave this review. I’m really happy that we were able to respond quickly to your needs. Maryellen is the best!

Marcelina Mabondo1 photo
9 months ago
Response from owner

Thank you for your review!

windham native
12 months ago

Recommend looking elsewhere. Having never gone through a legal action before it was difficult knowing when the process was going off the rails until my final judgement and the amount of time and money spent to get there with Port City Legal. Joe is very reassuring at initial meetings, but a very inexperienced lawyer took my case afterward and the case dragged out a year with an unfavorable result for me. To pursue further action would have cost me even more time and money that I had already lost. Do your research and demand progress dates be met. Do not assume you will be seen as a priority or that a highly experienced lawyer in the firm will be handling the bulk of your case.

Response from owner

I'm puzzled by this review. I have spoken to all of our attorneys and none are aware of a dissatisfied client. We also searched for clients from Windham and found none who had any issues with our work. It is not our practice to reassign clients to a different attorney once they hire us - in fact, our client engagement agreement specifies which attorney a client with work with. Our firm did experience the tragic and sudden death of Joe Lewis this January, so we then had to reassign his clients to other attorneys, but reassignments were collaborative and with full knowledge and consent of our clients. Please feel free to reach out to us directly if you want to follow up with this issue, but I don't think it's an accurate assessment of Port City Legal, where we make clients a priority every day.

Robert M. PaullLocal Guide
1 years ago

Friendly and competent representation from this group.

Response from owner

Thank you for your support.

mike carvell
1 years ago

I can't say enough good things about Port City Legal. They did an outstanding job for me. Joe's passing was such a shock. His professionalism, and kindness to both parties during a very hostile situation, showed so much class. I truly admired him. Erin , went above and beyond. She was not just a paralegal, she was a friend. The emotional support, she provide, kept me sane, and grounded. Her well spoken words, kept me focused, positive, and confident throughout such a troubling time. She is a real asset to the team.

Response from owner

Thank you for your review and kind thoughts. Erin is a treasure, and we're so glad to hear of her help to you.

DS P
1 years ago

I am a Connecticut resident; my wonderful Port City Legal attorney -- working with me over 2+ years via phone and email from up there in Maine on probate matters and rental real estate questions mainly -- is a knowledgeable, kind and eminently patient professional (believe me, I've *amply* tested the latter!): Maryellen Sullivan. I want to take this opportunity to highly recommend attorney Sullivan -- thus also PCL, for its lucky association with her! :-) If you need an attorney who is very responsive and easy to communicate with, who will do right by you whatever your situation, and refer you to someone else good should you have a particularly specialized issue that is somehow not within her realm of expertise -- please give Maryellen a try. I know that I, for one, am glad that I found her! (Thanks so much as always, Maryellen! -- and my thanks to Port City Legal, too; as a law firm you are to be commended for simply having had the good sense to bring somebody like her under your shingle!)

Response from owner

Thank you so much for your kind words. Your experience with Maryellen is the goal of all of our team here and why we do what we do. <br>

Lemuel Berry IIILocal Guide
1 years ago
Response from owner

Thanks, Lemuel. It's been a pleasure working with you.<br>

TannerLocal Guide
1 years ago
Response from owner

Thanks, Tanner. We think you're 5 stars too.

Clarence Douglas
1 years ago

Victoria and Taylor are the best duo I have had the honor of experiencing over the past two years. On the days I was not my best, they were always at their best. When things were the absolute worst that they could be, these two proved to be stronger and better than anything the opposition could throw my way. I am forever grateful for these two and my child is safe and taken care of because of these ladies. I recommend these ladies to anyone needing family legal services in Maine. They truly care about you and the best outcome that can be achieved for you.

Response from owner

Clarence: this is music to our ears. We try our very best to always keep our clients (and the kids!) front and center in everything we do. Thank you for taking the time to recognize Victoria and Taylor as the stars they are!

Chris PondLocal Guide18 photos
1 years ago

I highly recommend Port City Legal for anyone needing assistance with a probate court issue. My attorney, Maryellen Sullivan, did a great job. She is very knowledgeable and professional. She was able to take care of my case with a favorable result which my family is very grateful for. Terri Stevens is her legal assistant and also was extremely helpful. We appreciate all they have done.

Response from owner

HI Chris. Thank you so much for the shout out. Maryellen and Terri get it done all day long and I am really happy that they were able to help you and your family. Cheers!

Kathryn HoltkampLocal Guide23 photos
1 years ago

Joe and his team were very supportive and professional throughout the process of my divorce. They responded to all my questions and concerns in a timely way, and I am very appreciative of their kindness and professionalism. Great team all around to work with! 10/10 recommend!

Response from owner

Thanks for the warm words, Kathryn. It was our pleasure and honor to represent you and I wish you the very best in life moving forward!

Ben Kennedy
2 years ago

Working with Joe Lewis and his team was truly an excellent experience. Joe was very caring, kind, but also direct and set clear expectations for all the eventualities in my divorce case. He guided me through a settlement that allowed my family to avoid a trial. Had we gone to a trial, I have zero doubt our results would have been amazing. I highly recommend Joe and his team if you're looking for the best navigation through your worst possible days!

Response from owner

Thanks for the kind and gracious words, Ben. I am grateful to have had the opportunity to represent you and wish you the very best moving forward.

Brenda Bartucca
2 years ago

I had the very best experience with Port City Legal. I have a complex family law case, which also includes meeting with a lot of attorneys over the years. Attorney Lewis treated me and my case with the utmost professionalism, expertise, integrity, and compassion. He was always easy to communicate with, and very transparent. I was cared for, advocated for, and supported throughout my entire experience by the whole firm. Joe is a razor sharp skilled attorney who will fiercely advocate for what is right, striking a balance with exceptional legal strategy, and always place my child at the forefront of all decisions. Joe makes this look easy. However, there are so many times where there are paradoxes in the family law legal system, that make a singular focus almost impossible. With Joe, there are always possibilities and a pathway forward that keeps the integrity of the child’s best interest at heart. He makes this into an art form. Erin and Taylor were absolutely amazing to me. Whenever I communicated with them, I felt supported with such warmth. They both knew my case, and are so efficient, professional, and willing to go above and beyond. During my two day trial, both Erin and Taylor were so incredibly supportive. They showed up for me in ways that exceed all expectations. I felt so nervous preparing and attending trial, and I felt like they were holding my hand throughout it all. I am forever grateful for Attorney Lewis accepting my case. Due to the legal challenges, and complexity of my case the end result took over two years to accomplish. Attorney Lewis and his team stayed dedicated, and determined to a favorable outcome. The striking difference between Port City Legal, and all of the other firms that I have encountered, is that Attorney Lewis and his team believed in me. There were times in my case, when I thought that I should give up. They were always there to comfort, support, and motivate me. This team helped me to keep my hope alive, when I needed it most. This kind of kindness is extremely rare in family law. It is easy to become jaded to the system, for both professionals and parents. Joe and his team rise above the challenges, and always forged a path forward. I give my highest recommendation to this firm. My outcome was beyond my wildest dreams. The team is so dedicated, and truly committed to the best interest of the family. Throughout the stress and tears of seemingly endless setbacks, Attorney Lewis would find a way to bring laughter and a smile to my face, and help me to shift my perspective. I am a better person for knowing and working with Joe and his team. Thank you so very much for your dedication, hard work, and heart that you gave my case. I cannot thank you enough. All the best, Brenda Bartucca

Response from owner

Brenda. You honor us with your words. Every now and then a client and a case comes our way that invites the best of us as a firm. Thank you for allowing us to represent your interests. I know you will continue to put every effort into your family at every turn. Remember always that we are right here, prepared to be at your side and guarding your back!<br>- Joe

Karen N
2 years ago

I highly recommend Mary Ellen Sullivan as an estate lawyer. She handled the legal issues involved in my husband's estate with knowledge, skill, and professionalism. She was always willing to answer my questions and provided expert legal advice. Mary Ellen was also a strong advocate for me with the issues that required negotiation with my husband's family and legal counsel. She remained objective and respected my decisions throughout the long process of settling his estate. I appreciated her perspective and sense of humor which made a difficult time easier.

Response from owner

Thank you so much, Karen, for taking the time to leave a review for Maryellen. It can be really hard for people to select attorneys generally and I think that this sort of review really helps people separate the wheat from the chafe. I know Maryellen will be excited to hear about your feedback!

patrick sÞanczycLocal Guide
2 years ago

Port City Legal seemed understanding at first and I enjoyed my direct communications with Joe. Over the next 8 months I received invoices for a few and then a no contact. There was zero follow up from email and phone calls for simple items and an ongoing eight month email chain where Joe, Erin, or the billing side refused to follow up. Currently seeking another lawyer to get the retainer back or at least tied up in a legal situation such that Port City does not have those funds available due to abandonment of their client.

Response from owner

Hi Patrick. I'm sorry that you had the experience with us that you had, though I don't agree with your recollection of how things went over the course of our time together. I do want to reassure you that your retainer check is ~already~ in the mail and was put in the mail as soon as you requested it. I hope you have better success moving forward.

Brenda Damato
2 years ago

My husband and I needed a special needs trust, durable POA’s and wills. Previously we had worked with another local law firm where we waited an eternity to 1) get an appt 2) get any information. “Enough of this” I said! I Googled Port City Legal and Mary Ellen Sullivan called the next day. And we saw her in 2 weeks and had our documents 2 weeks after that! She was an absolute delight to work with. We walked in, unsure of what we needed and ignorant of the process and she patiently and professionally (with her vast legal knowledge) guided us in the right direction. She made the daunting process seem very simple and straightforward for a very reasonable fee. Mary Ellen is so personable, upbeat and knows her law inside and out and we had the most positive, satisfying experience with her and all the staff in the office. HIGHLY recommend Port City Legal and the incredible Mary Ellen Sullivan!

Response from owner

Hi Brenda. It was so nice of you to take the time to write a review of Maryellen. I know she was really appreciative to have you and your husband as clients and so am I. Thanks for choosing Port City Legal!

siham khudhur
3 years ago

Joe Lewis has helped me with my divorce Case . He was professional had the time to help me through my hard times also had sympathy and empathy to make it happen. I’m so glad that I did my case with Joe Lewis and his team that did extraordinary work and worked above and beyond to help thank you

Response from owner

A thousand thanks, Siham. It was my honor to be your attorney and I am very happy that everything worked out the way you wanted. Thank you again for being my client -- and for this kind review!

D In.
3 years ago

Maryellen did an excellent job!

Response from owner

Thanks for taking the time to leave a review!

Contact

Address
5 Moulton St 4th Floor, Portland, ME 04101

Google Profile

Rating
4.8 / 5
Reviews
82
Status
Open
Claimed
Yes
Photos
19

Add this badge to your website

Get embed code