Setter Roche Smith and Shellenberger, LLP

Great staff

Going through a divorce is never easy, and having international assets added an extra layer of complexity. From day one, Lisa Shellenberger and her assistant were exceptional - professional, attentive and genuinely compassionate. Lisa guided me through every step with patience and clarity, helping me understand my options and manage my expectations. Her calm confidence and expertise gave me reassurance at every turn. Communication was outstanding - prompt, thorough and thoughtful. What truly set Lisa apart was her humanity. She treated me not just as a client, but as a person navigating something deeply personal. Lisa's empathy, humor and care made all the difference. And while I like to think the good energy we all brought to the table helped a little, it was really Lisa and Jheadeaux's professionalism and heart that made the magic happen.

Catherine Tieman is the best when it comes to family matters! She has helped me on and off for 10 years! She helped me in a non-judgmental, caring and inspiring way. ✨She helped me navigate the despair that my alcohol addiction had brought to my life. Now that I have 2.5 years of sobriety. She helps me in a completely different way!! I can approach life in these parenting situations in a position of power. Which is the BEST, most rewarding feeling ever! I love updating her on the positive ways everything in my life has changed. I would recommend her too anyone. To me my kids are the most important thing in life. And she will help you navigate and fight. She’s a great mediator too. I can’t say enough good things about her. 💛💛💛

I cannot recommend Meggin Rutherford highly enough. Throughout my divorce, she demonstrated an exceptional depth of legal knowledge and a true commitment to her clients. She was always prepared, thorough, and strategic, ensuring that I understood every step of the process. What truly sets her apart is her genuine investment in her clients’ well-being—she consistently went above and beyond, providing not only expert legal guidance but also much-needed support and reassurance during a very difficult time. If you are looking for an attorney who is both highly skilled and truly cares, look no further than Meggin. In addition to Meggin's superior service, her paralegal Sarah is also incredible. There was never a time that I did not know what was happening, or that I did not get a quick response to a question thanks to Sarah. Her diligence and her quick response time was an incredible asset through such a stressful time. I can not give any higher recommendation than Meggin and Sarah!

I am a family law attorney and had the opportunity to mediate with Catherine Tiemen. I found her to be professional, unbiased, effective, and kind. Wouldn't hesitate to use her again.

Catherine Tieman is a crafty mediator that can make people feel good about compromising. I've used her as a mediator several times. She will nudge the parties toward resolution. One pair both hugged her at the end in a tough case. She knows how to settle cases.

I've had the good fortune to work with Meggin on multiple legal matters, and she is one of the best: incredibly knowledgeable, steady, thorough, and patient. Funny, too. She has a real talent for translating complex legalese in a way that anyone could grasp. Truly a pleasure to work with.

I reached out to this group because of their highly rated reviews and experience in the family law realm in Colorado. I had experience with a lawyer that did not seem invested in me and my family, which led to undesirable outcomes in court. When it comes to family law, there isn't room to mess around. I was so relieved to finally find Attorney Catherine Tieman, who was a smart, strong, and determined representative, who was able to help our case move forward. I am very satisfied with the relationship with Catherine and her team. The paralegals were very helpful and responsive.

I cannot speak highly enough about the exceptional service and legal expertise provided by Setter Roche and specifically Rachel Young. From the moment I reached out, I felt supported, informed, and—most importantly—heard. Family law matters are never easy, but this team brought clarity and confidence to every step of the process. Rachel was not only incredibly knowledgeable but also deeply compassionate. She took the time to understand the nuances of my case, explained all my options thoroughly, and advocated for me with integrity and precision. Communication was always timely, clear, and reassuring, which made an overwhelming situation significantly easier to navigate. What truly set this firm apart was their unwavering commitment to protecting my best interests and long-term well-being. Thanks to their dedication, we achieved an outcome that was successful. If you are looking for a legal team that blends professionalism, empathy, and sharp legal strategy, I wholeheartedly recommend Setter Roche. They are everything you’d hope for during some of life’s most difficult transitions and situations.

The team at Setter Roche Smith and Shellenberger made an otherwise unpleasant process navigable and easy to understand. I'd highly recommend them to anyone in need of representation for family law issues.

We hired Meggin for our second parent adoption. She was thorough, compassionate, and reliable. I would definitely hire her again.

They did great. I told them what I needed and they got it done quickly.

The entire team at Setter Roche Smith and Shellenberger, LLP exceeded my expectations throughout my divorce process. Throughout the process everyone we encountered was professional, attentive, and genuinely caring. They demonstrated exceptional expertise in family law, particularly in cases involving families with diverse and special needs children, offering tailored guidance and thoughtful solutions at every step. The staff was always prompt in communication, ensuring I stayed informed and empowered. I felt truly supported by a team that prioritized both legal success and personal well-being. Highly recommend!

Meggin Rutherford and her paralegal, Sarah Duff, are compassionate professionals who supported me through one of the most difficult times of my life. They successfully represented me in my divorce from an abusive narcissist who thought he was a lawyer despite being kicked out of law school and losing all of his frivolous lawsuits against perceived enemies. Needless to say, he was a nightmare to work with, but Meggin and Sarah did not put up with any of his nonsense. Eventually, he realized he was up against experienced professionals who would not be bullied by him, so he hired an attorney, which made the process easier for us. I came out of the divorce with what I wanted and ready to move forward with my life thanks to the excellent work of Meggin and her team!

I wouldn't say my case was complicated, but we ended up having sudden changes at the last minute. Meggin was able to update and correct our case and be ready for court. She always was a professional, but she made sure I was comfortable with each step and that we could get the best results. She was always honest, and she and her team were so quick to respond to any and all questions.

If you are in need of an ICWA expert I recommend Lisa Shellenberger.

Divorce is a thoroughly unpleasant experience, so it pays to have the right counsel on your side. Lisa Shellenberger (and her team) are the right people at this difficult time. She knows the law and supports her clients, but won't waste your time - and money - pursuing unrealistic approaches. She's thoughtful and thorough. I would - and will - highly recommend her to anyone facing the prospect of divorce.

Rachel and her team did an incredible job for me in a very complicated case. I liked that she was always available to email or talk to. If anyone was to have an estate issue, no matter the complexity, Rachel and her team will walk you through everything and make it all very easy to understand. I wouldn't hesitate to call on Rachel again as they offer other services besides what they did for me. Thank you for all you did Rachel! Sincerely, Joe

I worked with Rachel Young and she was great! She was very attentive and responded quickly to my questions. I am referring all my friends to her.